How to choose a Shopify marketing agency: 7 criteria
How a Shopify brand under $200K a month should choose a marketing agency: scope, who does the work, reporting, contract terms, cost, and when not to hire one.
Choose a Shopify marketing agency by judging it on seven things: scope, who actually does the work, proof from stores your size, reporting, what you own, contract terms and what it costs at your size. A good agency is a fair answer for some brands. A brand doing under $200K a month often needs to check first that the agency's size and price fit the store.
This guide is written for founders who are weighing that decision, not for agencies selling to them. Use it as a checklist on every call.
1. Start with scope, not the agency
Before you talk to anyone, write down the jobs you want done. Paid ads on Meta? Klaviyo email flows? Creative? Store design and checkout improvements? An agency that is excellent at one of these may be average at the others, and a bundle you do not need is the easiest way to overpay.
- Single channel: you want ads or email, and nothing else.
- Full stack: ads, email, creative and reporting under one roof.
- Advice only: a strategist who tells you what to do while your team executes.
Ask each agency to map your goals to channels, timelines and reporting. If the answer is a generic package, they have not listened.
2. Find out who does the work
The person who sells you is rarely the person who runs your account. Ask who will be your day to day contact, how many other brands they handle, and who writes the ads and the emails. Ask to meet that person before you sign.
For a small store this matters more than the logo list. A junior manager with thirty accounts will give you a different result than a senior operator with eight.
3. Ask for proof from stores like yours
Case studies from brands ten times your size say little about what will happen to you. Shopify's own guide to hiring an agency puts it plainly: "Look for an agency with case studies of work with past clients it's willing to share." It adds that a digital marketing agency with proven success "should also have no problem providing you with a few references."
Do both. Read the case studies for the situation, not the headline number: what was the starting point, what changed, and over how long? Then call two references and ask what went wrong, not only what went well.
4. Check how they report
Reporting is where weak agencies hide. You should be able to read it and tie it back to your own Shopify numbers. The same Shopify guide sets a floor: spend by channel, what that spend brought in, what a customer cost to win, and how purchase rates are trending.
Ask for a sample report. Then ask how they handle the gaps: ad platforms and Shopify rarely agree to the dollar, so a good agency explains the difference instead of picking the flattering number.
5. Know what you own
The ad account, the Klaviyo account, the customer list and the creative should all be yours. Shopify's guide frames the question this way: "Ask who owns the ad accounts and data, what access you'll have, and what happens if you end the relationship."
If an agency runs your ads from its own ad account, you can lose your history the day you leave. Insist on running everything inside accounts you own, with them added as users.
6. Read the contract before the pitch deck
Look for four things:
- Term: a month-to-month arrangement or a minimum commitment, and what it takes to exit.
- Fees: a flat retainer, a percentage of ad spend, or both, and what is charged on top.
- Ad spend: whether your media budget is separate from the fee, and who controls it.
- Deliverables: what is promised each month in plain terms, such as number of creatives and emails.
Be wary of anyone who promises a specific return. Nobody controls how your customers behave, and a promise like that tells you how they sell, not how they work. The same guide treats a lack of openness as a warning sign: "Lack of transparency should be a red flag."
7. Match the price to your size
This is where small brands get hurt. Agency retainers are set by the agency's costs, not by your sales, so a fee that suits a large brand can swallow the margin of a small store. Work out what the fee is as a share of your monthly sales and your gross profit before you go further, then ask every agency for a written quote against your exact scope.
Remember the ad spend on top. If the fee leaves you too little to spend on ads, the arrangement cannot work however good the team is.
A simple scoring sheet
| Criterion | What a good answer sounds like | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Tied to your goals and channels | One package for everyone |
| People | Named contact, named creative lead | "The team" with no names |
| Proof | Stores your size, references offered | Only big logos |
| Reporting | Spend, what it brought in, cost per customer | Impressions and clicks only |
| Ownership | You own every account | Their ad account, their list |
| Contract | Clear term and exit | Long lock-in, vague deliverables |
| Price | Written quote against scope | Price only after a long pitch |
Score each agency from one to five on every row. If an agency cannot answer a row in writing, that is your answer.
When an agency is the right call
An agency makes sense when you have a proven product, enough margin to pay a retainer and still fund ads, and a need for senior judgment you cannot hire in house. It also makes sense when you want a team to take a whole channel off your plate and you are willing to manage the relationship.
It is a weaker fit when the store is still finding its first repeatable customers, when the retainer would be a large share of sales, or when you would rather see and control the work yourself.
The other options
Agencies are one of four routes. A freelancer costs less and gives you a single skilled person, with the risk that one person is also your single point of failure. Hiring in house gives control but adds salary and management. Doing it yourself costs time. Software is the fourth: funnls, for example, builds the store, makes the ad creative, runs the ads and the Klaviyo email flows and reports what is working, for a monthly price instead of a retainer. It suits a founder who wants the work done without managing people, and it is not the right tool for someone who wants a human strategist on every call.
Whichever route you pick, the seven criteria above still apply: clear scope, named people, proof, honest reporting, ownership, fair terms and a price that fits.
See how funnls would run your store
Frequently asked questions
How do I choose a Shopify marketing agency?
Write down the jobs you need done, then judge each agency on scope, who does the work, proof from stores your size, reporting, ownership of your accounts, contract terms and price. Ask for references, a sample report and a written quote. Pick the one that answers each point in writing.
What should a Shopify marketing agency report to me?
At a minimum, spend by channel, what that spend brought in, what each customer cost to win and how purchase rates are trending, shown in a way you can compare with your own Shopify numbers. A good agency also explains where ad platform figures and Shopify disagree instead of choosing the flattering number.
Should I own my ad accounts when I hire an agency?
Yes. Your ad accounts, Klaviyo account, customer list and creative should sit in accounts you own, with the agency added as a user. That way your history and data stay with you if you end the relationship.
When is a marketing agency not worth it for a small store?
When the retainer would take a large share of your sales, when you have not yet found a repeatable customer, or when you want to control the work yourself. In those cases a freelancer, software or doing it yourself may fit better.